Investment strategies can seem complex, particularly when weighing the options between active and passive investing approaches. The term passive investing may imply minimal involvement, but the truth is quite the opposite. A deeper examination shows that even passive strategies necessitate significant oversight and regular adjustments.
For example, our automated investment service employs a blend of both strategies, primarily favoring passive methods. However, each trading day involves considerable activity as we closely monitor and manage our portfolios.
Additionally, we frequently modify asset allocations to align with current global market conditions and long-term forecasts, adding a dynamic aspect to what is frequently termed passive investing.
Table of Contents:
Defining active and passive investing
At their essence, both active investing and passive investing involve decisions regarding fund allocation. This process can engage individual investors, professionals, or entire investment firms. The primary difference lies in their objectives and associated costs.
Evaluating market performance
Many investors aim to outperform the market, but achieving this consistently over time can prove challenging. Consider the S&P 500, a benchmark for U.S. large-cap stocks. Research indicates that fewer than 15% of actively managed funds have successfully exceeded its performance over a five-year period or longer.
Nonetheless, active investing retains a legitimate role, even among those with a long-term, conservative outlook. Certain markets, particularly smaller or developing ones, may not be as efficiently priced as the S&P 500. With the right insights and expertise, investors can uncover valuable opportunities in these less efficient markets, especially in sectors like fixed income investments.
Identifying the right investment team
When investing in an actively managed fund, considering the management team is crucial. Their experience and track record can significantly impact the fund’s success. Therefore, we conduct comprehensive quantitative and qualitative analyses to evaluate the teams managing the ETFs included in our portfolios.
Exploring niche markets
In some cases, a passive index fund may not even be available for certain niche markets. A notable example is the Academy Veteran Bond ETF (VETZ), an actively managed fund that invests in loans for active and retired U.S. military personnel and the families of fallen service members. This aligns with our Socially Responsible Investing initiative, providing a unique investment opportunity.
Furthermore, many individual investors enjoy managing a portion of their investments. A survey among Betterment customers revealed that approximately three-quarters of them incorporate self-directed investments alongside their managed portfolios. This combination of self-direction can introduce an element of excitement and education into the investing process.
The evolving landscape of investing
The distinction between active and passive investing is also evident in portfolio composition. Stock indices are weighted by the market capitalization of their constituent companies, which change over time. This characteristic allows indices and their tracking funds to adjust naturally, with underperforming stocks gradually decreasing in weight while top performers gain prominence. Consequently, the current S&P 500 differs markedly from its previous iterations.
Additionally, there exists a hybrid model known as smart beta, where fund managers begin with a predefined index and then make active adjustments based on various quantitative factors. One example of this method is the Goldman Sachs Smart Beta portfolio, which focuses on investing in companies exhibiting specific desirable traits.
For example, our automated investment service employs a blend of both strategies, primarily favoring passive methods. However, each trading day involves considerable activity as we closely monitor and manage our portfolios. Additionally, we frequently modify asset allocations to align with current global market conditions and long-term forecasts, adding a dynamic aspect to what is frequently termed passive investing.0
