Investing in the stock market often leads to the comparison of time spent in the market versus attempting to time the market. Experienced investors generally agree that patience is beneficial, especially when focusing on quality stocks. These stocks represent companies with strong returns on equity, consistent earnings, and manageable debt levels. Research indicates that such quality shares tend to outperform broader market averages over extended periods.
Investors frequently inquire about their portfolio’s quarterly results or predictions for short-term market movements.
While these inquiries are valid, they may not effectively capture the essence of long-term investment success. For instance, the MSCI World Index has experienced notable fluctuations, highlighting the unpredictable nature of short-term returns.
Table of Contents:
The impact of market events on investment returns
In, the inauguration of President Trump resulted in corporate tax cuts and deregulations, which generally favored market growth. Despite this, the MSCI World Index declined by 3.6% during the first quarter. Conversely, a series of tariffs introduced in April raised concerns about economic repercussions, yet the index rebounded with a remarkable 9.5% increase in the second quarter, followed by an additional 7% rise by October.
Understanding the challenges of market timing
Many investors claim expertise in timing stock market fluctuations; however, substantial evidence suggests that attempting to time the market often results in disappointing returns. Historical data reveals that systematic trends in the stock market typically manifest over the long term, with quality stocks consistently outperforming their counterparts.
Investment strategies that focus on quality stocks generally involve a mix of periods of excellent performance and times of underperformance. A closer look at the MSCI World Quality Index—which encompasses 300 of the highest-quality companies—compared to the broader MSCI World Index and the MSCI World Growth Index reveals intriguing insights.
Long-term performance metrics of quality stocks
Data spanning from December 2008 to September 2025 illustrates the resilience of quality stocks. The longer the investment horizon, the more pronounced the outperformance of the MSCI World Quality Index becomes relative to the broader index. This trend is visually represented in various performance charts.
Notably, the MSCI World Quality Index has outperformed the broader market across all ten-year timeframes since 1998, showcasing remarkable consistency. This sustained performance indicates that quality stocks often provide more reliable returns over extended periods.
Exploring the dynamics of quality versus growth stocks
Interestingly, while quality shares have outperformed growth stocks in the long run, they have occasionally shown marginal underperformance in the short term. For instance, during the COVID-19 pandemic, there was a surge in interest for growth stocks like Zoom and Peloton, leading to six consecutive quarters of quality stocks trailing behind. Despite this, the ten-year absolute returns for quality stocks remained impressive, ranging from 178% to 335% during those periods.
It is essential to note the differing income characteristics of these stock types. As of September 2025, the MSCI World Quality Index boasted a dividend yield of 1.25%, nearly double that of the MSCI World Growth Index at 0.69%. This disparity highlights that quality stocks deliver returns through both capital appreciation and dividends, providing a more diversified investment approach.
Maintaining focus on quality investments
As active portfolio managers focusing on quality investments, our strategy involves more than merely adhering to a quality benchmark. We assess the unique characteristics of these quality businesses, evaluating their competitive advantages and growth prospects. Furthermore, we remain vigilant in avoiding companies that may be overvalued, as this can jeopardize long-term investor returns.
Investors frequently inquire about their portfolio’s quarterly results or predictions for short-term market movements. While these inquiries are valid, they may not effectively capture the essence of long-term investment success. For instance, the MSCI World Index has experienced notable fluctuations, highlighting the unpredictable nature of short-term returns.0
Investors frequently inquire about their portfolio’s quarterly results or predictions for short-term market movements. While these inquiries are valid, they may not effectively capture the essence of long-term investment success. For instance, the MSCI World Index has experienced notable fluctuations, highlighting the unpredictable nature of short-term returns.1
