Navigating the Rental Market: Key Dynamics in Major Cities

The quest to swiftly occupy rental units is a common aspiration for landlords. However, urban areas face a significant challenge: meeting the overwhelming demand for housing.

Insights from RentCafé reveal a struggle among landlords to keep pace with tenant demand. The competition for available rentals has intensified, leading to rapid occupancy rates in some cities. Developers are unable to construct new housing quickly enough to satisfy the market.

Table of Contents:

Key cities experiencing rental surges

In light of a recent downturn in home sales across regions like South Florida, the rental market has become increasingly competitive. Miami, according to RentCafé, stands out as a premier rental hotspot, followed closely by Chicago. The reasons behind this demand differ between the two cities.

Elevated mortgage rates have deterred potential homebuyers, resulting in heightened interest in rental properties. This trend is particularly evident in high-cost markets like Miami, which boasts a favorable climate, no state income tax, and appealing amenities. As summer approached, RentCafé reported Florida as the top destination for apartment seekers.

Miami’s rental market dynamics

Miami’s appeal has attracted various corporate entities and affluent individuals, leading to an average of just 32 days for units to be leased. The city has seen an astonishing ratio of 19 prospective renters for every available apartment, more than double the national average. This scarcity has encouraged 71.8% of current tenants to renew their leases, driving occupancy rates up to 96.5%.

The Chicago rental scene

Conversely, Chicago presents its unique challenges in the rental market. With a historical emphasis on maintaining single-family home neighborhoods in the suburbs—such as Aurora, Naperville, Joliet, and Elgin—finding rental housing can be particularly tough. This has led to a 60% lease renewal rate as many tenants choose to stay put, resulting in an occupancy rate of 95.4%. Each available apartment in Chicago typically garners interest from about 16 potential renters, filling up in an average of 29 days.

The importance of lease renewals

As the 2025 leasing season commenced, national renewal rates saw a slight increase to 62.7%, up from 62% in the previous year, underscoring the significance of tenant retention. The costs associated with tenant turnover can be substantial, including expenses related to renovations, marketing, and lost rental income. Hence, landlords are increasingly motivated to retain dependable tenants.

A report from Zego highlights that the average resident retention rate for multifamily properties has reached 63%, marking the highest level since tracking began in 2021. Notably, the number of property management firms aiming for retention rates of 70% or more has tripled in the last four years.

Housing shortages across the U.S.

In the Twin Cities of Minneapolis and St. Paul, a pronounced housing deficit persists, as indicated by the Minnesota Realtors March 2025 Housing Market Report. Zoning regulations and local opposition—often referred to as NIMBYism (Not In My Backyard)—have been identified as contributing factors. Minneapolis ranks lowest among 128 Midwest cities in terms of new housing developments, resulting in a nearly $200 monthly rent increase from 2019 to 2025. In fact, rents for non-subsidized apartments have now surpassed the average mortgage payment for single-family homes.

As documented by The Wall Street Journal, Milwaukee has earned the title of “One of America’s Most Cutthroat Rental Markets.” The city grapples with extreme rental demand due to slow development, with local experts noting that the lack of new housing stock is a primary driver of its competitive market.